I have done some more thinking about the issue of business consolidation in the U.S.
The most striking thing about all this is that the media are entirely oblivious to this major development …
Stay informed about your community and support local independent journalism.
Subscribe to The River Reporter today. click here
This item is available in full to subscribers.
Please log in to continue |
I have done some more thinking about the issue of business consolidation in the U.S.
The most striking thing about all this is that the media are entirely oblivious to this major development affecting the lives of millions. It started in a big way during the second term of President Obama, and the problem began with increased numbers of regulations.
Regulations hurt businesses
President Obama's new regulations surely contributed to it, though I do not believe that is the main reason. During one 12-month period, President Obama's administration issued 86,000 new regulations. That hampered business in a curious way—nobody could follow the multitude of these new regulations. Surely, when President Trump's first term started, he canceled most of the new regulations and instituted a rule that any future new regulation must be compensated for by canceling one existing regulation. American business started booming naturally and immediately.
But in the mortgage industry with which I am familiar, business became concentrated in the hands of a few largest nationwide lenders, who employed an army of lawyers overseeing "compliance" that small mortgage bankers and mortgage brokers were not able to afford. Immediately, new companies sprang up, offering "compliance for hire" that solved the manpower problem but not the cost of services problem.
And as nobody seems to notice and be concerned about it—neither the media nor the politicians—this situation lasts to this day. When I was returning my three licenses to the NYS Department of Financial Services, the official said, "We see this every day. This has now become the game only for the big boys."
Previously, we were competing with the big boys precisely in the areas of efficiency, local knowledge and costs.
But I do not believe that this was the main problem and the main reason for the ongoing consolidation of all kinds of business (mortgages, pharmacies, doctors, grocery stores, fishmongers, etc.). So what is the reason?
State control started the process
The left has the simple dictum that President Obama articulated when he said that if you have a successful business, it was not you who made it but the society, and "At one point you have enough" (he meant money).
Then the people who worked all their lives for somebody else are inclined to badmouth the "rich" who provide the employment for them and are the source of all the progress and innovation. This is how communism nearly won all over the world in the previous century—through the politics of envy.
America used to be the place where it was relatively easy, and it is still the easiest place, to start a business. (In France, you need some 300 permits before you can start a new factory.) But this is now harder than before even here.
Secondly, the left labors under the misguided notion articulated by President Obama with his "At one point you have had enough [money]." So was the $6 million enough that he earned from his books, such as his memoir? Or is nearly $1 trillion enough that Elon Musk is now worth?
Where socialism begins
President Obama had a slideshow of Julia, a fictitious person, who was taken care of by the government from cradle to grave using the money extracted via more taxation for the "rich." (At this junction, we should remind ourselves that the American tax system is the most progressive in the world.)
[Ed. note: You can read an abstract of the campaign at https://digitalcommons.pepperdine.edu/ppr/vol11/iss1/1/.]
The idea that somebody has earned enough money and should stop is very close to the idea of taking the money away from the "rich" and distributing it among the "needy."
We have done that in communist Czechoslovakia. We took all the money from the rich; “profit” was a bad word, it was made illegal—and it made all of us poor!
Why? Simple! The ability to make money is the source of all innovation in society.
We abolished that incentive in communist Czechoslovakia and, consequently, we became retarded in comparison to the West.
An engineer working in the Research Institute for Telecommunication once told me, "We are 40 years behind the West in telephony." (I waited for seven years to have a telephone line installed in my apartment.)
But none of this is limited just to the communist countries. In socialist Sweden, which is held by some uninformed here as an ideal, there was no new major business enterprise started in the last 25 years after IKEA and similar ones sprang up—in the past. Jeffrey Sachs (of Columbia University) is the founding co-editor of the World Happiness Report. The list consistently names one of the socialist Scandinavian countries as the happiest country. (The owner of IKEA escaped and lived in Switzerland, same as the well-known movie director Ingmar Bergman, who was falsely accused of tax evasion and was arrested at 2 a.m. at his home before he could clear himself.)
The Happiness Report is based on self-evaluation expressed as a so-called Cantril Ladder. The happiest country in the world is currently Finland. Said a Finnish journalist: "We are surprised and we did not know this. It may be because our expectations are lower."
We can contrast that with the numerous large companies appearing in the United States all the time, from Google and Microsoft to the recent AI companies.
So why are businesses consolidating?
So what are the main reasons for the tremendous consolidation of American business into large business conglomerates, which remains largely unnoticed, unmentioned and under the radar?
(Ayn Rand's Objectivism is a little overwrought in this regard. It should be of interest to us that Russian Bolsheviks nationalized her father's pharmacy after the
Bolshevik Revolution of 1917, leaving the family barely enough to survive before she escaped to the West.)
But as a rather unpleasant byproduct of this development, the former business owners are hurt as they become employees of large business conglomerates rather than business owners themselves. (Mortgage bankers and brokers become the employees of the largest banks, and pharmacists, butchers, fishmongers and former grocery store owners are now working for large supermarket chains; doctors are closing their offices to work for large medical services companies.)
However, the consumer without any question benefits from the economies of scale. Consider that our supermarket Shoprite, a chain founded in 1946 and which now sports 400 stores, is frequently offering unbelievably low prices. This is how the British magazine The Economist could recently write: "The United States economy has left the economies of all developed countries in the dust. The American productivity remains the highest in the world."
I believe that the sole reason for this consolidation of American business into large enterprises, and the associated decline in the ease with which one can start a new business, is the fabulous riches one can earn in America in business. It now takes a lot of money to buy all the small businesses and consolidate them into a large business enterprise. And these monies, earned in other businesses, are now available in amounts never seen before.
As President Calvin Coolidge said in his speech in 1925, "the chief business of American people is business." And America is still the place where one starting a business faces lower barriers than in other countries of the world.
Ivan Orisek contributes opinion columns to the River Reporter. He lives in Forestburgh, NY.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here