Multiple lawsuits filed over YMCA project

By SONIA AHMED
Posted 11/16/26

CHERRY RIDGE, PA — About a month after the Wayne County YMCA claimed that its new $20 million project was deemed approved and Cherry Ridge Township denied those claims, two lawsuits have been filed …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Multiple lawsuits filed over YMCA project

Posted

CHERRY RIDGE, PA — About a month after the Wayne County YMCA claimed that its new $20 million project was deemed approved and Cherry Ridge Township denied those claims, two lawsuits have been filed and another determination against the project has been made.

Background

The proposed $20 million YMCA was to sit off Spinner Road and Lienert Lane on half of a 40-acre parcel of land. The other 20 acres was to be used for a county commissioner Agriculture Innovation Center, but plans were pulled due to high costs and the YMCA reapplied alone.

Cherry Ridge Township has been holding conditional use hearings for the project to determine if it is allowed in its rural development district. Residents have raised concerns about the project regarding location, infrastructure, traffic and more as opposed to the YMCA itself.

The last hearing, which was originally scheduled on August 19, was moved to October 21 due to the township’s failure to properly post the hearing.

Lawsuits and decisions

The Cherry Ridge Township board of supervisors made a final decision regarding the YMCA application on Thursday, November 12. Many residents expressed concern over the deemed approval and the township’s responsibilities.

Shaun Dieterich, a resident and president of the citizen’s group the Committee for Responsible Development (CRD) said that he was “concerned that it happened two times that somebody couldn’t put a sign in the ground in a timely manner that led to a deemed approval.”

Dieterich has placed “Keep Cherry Ridge Rural, No Sewer,” signs throughout the Honesdale area to spread awareness of the project.

“The township does not agree that there was a deemed approval that took place here,” township solicitor Brendan Ellis responded. “They [the YMCA] can assert that the moon is green. We don’t agree with that assertion.”

A motion was passed to dismiss and deny the YMCA’s application.

Earlier that same day, the YMCA filed a complaint against Cherry Ridge Township. The complaint claims that since hearings began on June 17, the township did not meet a 90-day deadline to make a decision and that therefore, the project has been deemed approved.

Cherry Ridge Township’s zoning code states that the board of supervisors must make a decision within 90 days of receiving an application, otherwise, the application will be “deemed approved.”

The YMCA lawsuit asks that the court order the township to issue a conditional use permit so the YMCA can start building on its property. It also asks that the township pay for attorneys fees and damages.

On November 10, attorney Ronald Bugaj, who represents intervenors and residents Carol and Mark Lienert, filed an appeal to the YMCA’s deemed approval. The appeal asks that the YMCA’s deemed approval be found invalid. The filing alleges that the YMCA agreed to all extensions of time, both for the first hearing and the last hearing that was moved from August 19 to October 21.

Dieterich plans to also file an appeal to the YMCA’s deemed approval, representing himself.

His appeal states that as someone in close proximity to the project, he has concerns about “potential noise, exterior lighting, and visual impacts of the proposed facility.”

Dieterich, who applied but was not accepted as an intervenor during the YMCA’s conditional use hearings, asks that the court finds the YMCA’s deemed approval invalid and that, if it were to apply again, a determination be made regarding his objector status.

Who has authority?

Carol Lienert commented during the Thursday meeting that when the YMCA first proposed the project, she invited members affiliated with the organization to her house for clarity, but none came.

“Our concern is the safety of our homes, to make sure that our homes don’t get flooded out, that our pond that we use for fishing does not get contaminated,” she said. “The YMCA is an amazing, positive organization. I’m just disappointed in how this is being handled.”

Ellis said that concerns about water, noise, lighting and more are land development concerns, not concerns for conditional use hearings.

“This hearing was for zoning. Does that use qualify in the district? That’s all. Not the size of the building, not the color of the building, not the water protections that are gonna be required. Those aren’t part of the zoning decision,” he responded.

Cherry Ridge Township board chairman David Sporer said that the township is limited in what conditions they can put on land usage.

“My family’s been on Spinner Road since 1850,” Sporer continued, adding that there are now residences where farmlands used to exist in the township. “We don’t like to see change, but that’s not my property. We can put conditions on what someone does on the property only to a certain point.”

Mark Lienert asked the supervisors why the project wasn’t reviewed by county commissioners.

“We asked the county if they wanted to review it, and they said it was not necessary to review it, as it is a conditional use hearing and has nothing to do with the county,” Sporer said.

Cherry Ridge Township is located within Wayne County. During a county commissioner meeting Thursday morning, the commissioners passed a motion to approve and submit a Wayne County YMCA Pennsylvania Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program (RACP) project management plan. The YMCA has previously been granted $1.25 million for the project from RACP.

When asked about residents’ concerns or the deemed approval, commissioner chairman Brian Smith told the River Reporter that “it has become a legal battle that we’re not gonna touch with a 10-foot pole.”

“What a way to not express leadership,” Dennis Cheng, Cherry Ridge resident and opposer to the project told the River Reporter in response to the commissioners statement.

The township’s future

Carol Lienert urged the township to look towards the future and update local ordinances as a result of the YMCA’s process.

Sporer said he welcomed any suggestions residents had for updates to zoning ordinances.

Ellis said that in his view, the conditional use hearings had both successes and failures. He agreed with residents that the zoning ordinances, which were written in the 1990s, could use an update.

“There was no shouting here. There were neighbors that showed up because they wanted to be heard.” he remarked about things that went well during the process. “This isn’t closure. The YMCA had the right to do what they did and they’re going to ask someone to make their decisions easier. I don’t know where it ends, but it will end. Everyone will be heard and a good decision will be made.”

Editor’s note: The YMCA’s attorney Mark Zimmer chose not to comment except through filings. The YMCA board of directors president Sherman Bronson and board member Keith Gunuskey did not respond to requests for comment.

Wayne County YMCA, Cherry Ridge Township, lawsuits, zoning code

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here