Pushing for more sunlight; legislator campaigns against caucus system
July 24, 2012 —
As a general rule, when making decisions about matters that will impact the public, elected officials in New York State are required to deliberate in public. But one important exception to the rule is the political caucus. When members of the same political party get together, they are allowed to discuss county business, and just about anything else they want to discuss, with no fear of running afoul of the state’s Open Meetings Law.
It was not always so. After the law was passed in 1997, according to the Committee on Open Government, “judicial decisions indicated that the exemption pertained only to discussions of political party business.” That changed in 1985, when the law was amended to say that caucuses were exempt from the law “without regard to the subject matter under discussion.”
In Sullivan County, that means that the seven Democrats can meet behind closed doors and discuss important matters with no or limited input from the two Republican members. Democratic legislator Cindy Geiger thinks the practice should be changed, and it was discussed at the Government Center on July 19.
Geiger told The River Reporter, “What happens in the discussion is very different when all nine legislators are at the table because the information is flowing among all nine.” She said that, once she was elected and saw how the political caucus process works, “I couldn’t get over the fact that all nine legislators were not receiving the same information.”
Therefore, she has proposed a resolution that would prohibit the discussion of public business, which at least one other municipality in the state has done.
Some of her Democratic colleagues don’t agree with her. Legislator Jonathan Rouis said during discussion at the meeting that, unlike other counties, Sullivan only has nine legislators, and most matters get a full discussion. He added that usually every resolution is ultimately voted on by all nine lawmakers.
Members of the public who spoke on the issue sided with Geiger. David Colavito said that the issue to him is personal because his elected representative at the county is Republican Alan Sorensen, “and he’s in the minority, and I don’t know how he gets to represent me if he’s not in the loop.” He said he agreed with Sorensen, who said, “Just because you can do something doesn’t mean that you should.”